Jannik Sinner, currently competing at the ATP Finals in Turin, finds himself once again at the center of a cultural debate. After past accusations of being insufficiently patriotic, the world number one is now being criticized for expressing his Italian identity too strongly. The latest reaction comes from the South Tyrolean Schützen, a traditional group known for defending regional autonomy and cultural heritage.
The statement that sparked controversy
In a recent interview with Sky Sport, Sinner said he was “proud to be Italian and happy to have been born here, not in Austria.” The comment was intended to silence earlier criticism, including those from journalist Bruno Vespa, who questioned why Italians should support Sinner after his decision to skip the Davis Cup. However, the remark drew a strong response from the Schützen, who have historically opposed South Tyrolean athletes displaying Italian symbols or singing the national anthem.
The Schützen’s open letter
Christoph Schmid, commander of the Schützen in Alto Adige, addressed Sinner in an open letter, urging him to consider the broader impact of his words. “In a free society, everyone must be able to define their own identity,” Schmid wrote. He warned that such statements, especially from high-profile figures, could be misinterpreted and politicized.
“You know well that statements like this, especially when made by someone so well-known, have an effect that goes far beyond sport,” the letter continued. “They are welcomed by Italian nationalists, while here they raise concern. Because they touch on central issues for us: our language, our history, our identity.”
A call for sensitivity and respect
The Schützen emphasized the importance of respecting South Tyrolean autonomy and cultural diversity. “It hurts when prominent figures from our region, with hasty words, give the impression that this historical bond with Austria and the hard-won autonomy have lost meaning,”
Schmid added. The group asked Sinner to speak thoughtfully about national identity in the future, acknowledging the region’s complex cultural landscape.“Speak of your Italian identity if you wish, but do so with respect for those who feel South Tyrolean, Ladin, or part of other minorities,” the letter urged. “You, who travel the world, know well that openness and diversity are not weaknesses, but strengths.”
Kompatscher calls for calm
South Tyrolean governor Arno Kompatscher also weighed in, calling for calm and support. “I simply ask that we leave him in peace and let him play tennis,” Kompatscher said. “Let’s just cheer for him at the ATP Finals in Turin and support him in his fight for the number one ranking.”
Jannik Sinner in 2025
Ranked no.1, the Italian played his last match on the 2nd of November when he overcame world no.8 Felix Auger-Aliassime 6-4 7-6(4) in the final in Paris to win his 24th career title.
At present, during this year Jannik achieved a 53-6 match record. The Italian conquered 5 titles in 2025 at the Australian Open, Wimbledon, Beijing, Vienna and Paris. The Italian was the runner-up in Rome, French Open, Cincinnati and U.S. Open.